1. What is the ruling if true dawn begins while someone is having intercourse and he withdraws immediately?
- His fast is valid and he does not have to do anything. (correct answer)
- His fast is invalid and he must always offer expiation.
- His fast is valid only if he did not hear the adhan.
- His fast is invalid unless he did not ejaculate.
Why
When true dawn begins, the fasting person must stop eating, drinking, intercourse, and anything else that breaks the fast. If true dawn begins while a man is having intercourse and he withdraws immediately, his fast is valid and he owes nothing. If he knowingly continues after becoming aware that dawn has broken, then the fast is invalid and he must make up the day and offer expiation. If the adhan is based only on timetables and he is not certain dawn has actually broken, the source notes a concession, but the safer course is to stop as soon as the adhan is heard.