1. What was Allah’s plan for Prophet Yoosuf عليه السلام regarding his brother?
- A good plan that allowed him to keep his brother and reunite his family. (correct answer)
- A sinful lie from Yoosuf عليه السلام.
- A prohibited act of injustice.
- A plan to harm his brother.
Why
The source explains that the incident was not lying or prohibited deceit by Prophet Yoosuf عليه السلام. Allah made easy for him a plan that enabled him to keep his brother with him, because under the king’s law he would not have been able to do so. The wording of the Qur’an avoids saying that the brother stole; rather, the bowl was brought out of his bag. The caller may have spoken based on what he thought, and Yoosuf عليه السلام used truthful double entendre. The plan led to good outcomes: the truth became clear, the brothers recognized their wrongdoing, the family was reunited, and Allah’s promise to Yoosuf and Ya‘qoob عليهما السلام was fulfilled.