1. Why must the required hadiy or expiatory sacrifice of Hajj be slaughtered in the Haram?
- Because Allah prescribed the Haram as the place for this ritual sacrifice. (correct answer)
- Because meat cannot be distributed outside Makkah in any circumstance.
- Because it is merely easier for pilgrims already in Makkah.
- Because the pilgrim’s home country has no poor people.
Why
The required hadiy for tamattu‘ and qiraan, and sacrifices required for omitting obligatory actions, must be slaughtered in the Haram and are not acceptable elsewhere. The source explains that hadiy refers to something brought as a gift to a place, and its place is the Haram. The deeper wisdom is obedience to Allah’s command: just as tawaf, ‘Arafah, Muzdalifah, and stoning the Jamarat have prescribed places, the required sacrifice also has its prescribed place.