1. According to the view favored in the source, can Hajj be performed on behalf of someone who was able to do obligatory Hajj but neglected it until death?
- No, it will not count for him because he neglected an immediate obligation without excuse. (correct answer)
- Yes, it automatically counts in every case.
- Only if the heirs agree unanimously.
- Only if the Hajj is repeated three times.
Why
The scholars differed concerning someone who was able to do obligatory Hajj but delayed it out of negligence until death. Some said Hajj may be performed on his behalf and will benefit him. The view favored in the source is that it will not count for him because he failed, without excuse, to do an act of worship that was obligatory and should have been done immediately. This differs from cases where a person was not negligent or had a valid excuse.