1. If someone intended Hajj at the miqat but then performed ‘umrah actions with the group before Hajj, what is the ruling?
- The Hajj is valid, and the ‘umrah supersedes the initial Hajj intention. (correct answer)
- The Hajj is invalid because the person did not intend ‘umrah at the miqat.
- The person must repeat Hajj the following year.
- The person must stop all rituals immediately.
Why
If someone entered ihram intending Hajj, then reached Makkah and performed ‘umrah with the people, their Hajj is valid and that ‘umrah supersedes the Hajj they first intended. This is supported by the Prophet ﷺ instructing some Companions who had intended Hajj to make it ‘umrah, except those who had brought a hadiy. A pilgrim should still learn the rulings of Hajj and ‘umrah before performing them, but following the people in the essential actions may still result in a valid Hajj.