1. What happens if someone could afford udhiyah but did not offer it for several past years?
- They missed reward, but they do not have to make up past years unless they had made a vow. (correct answer)
- They must make up every missed udhiyah.
- They committed a major sin in every case.
- They must offer a smaller sacrifice as compensation.
Why
Udhiyah is Sunnah mu’akkadah for the one who can afford it, according to the correct view cited, and there is no sin on the one who does not offer it. If someone did not offer udhiyah in past years, they missed a great reward, but they do not have to make up those years because the time for the voluntary sacrifice has passed. The exception is if the person had made a vow to offer a sacrifice; in that case, fulfilling the vow is obligatory.