The Committed Believer · Sacrifice & the Newborn

Valid Sacrifice and Aqeeqah Practices

Explore rulings on sacrifice validity, animal types, and witnessing in Islamic law.

6 questions · Medium · about 4 minutes

Test yourself properly, with scoring and instant feedback.

6 questions, about 4 minutes.

Take the quiz
Show questions and answers Spoilers: every answer and explanation for all 6 questions.

1. If a designated udhiyah animal is slaughtered without the owner’s explicit verbal instruction, when may the udhiyah still be valid?

  • When it is slaughtered at the proper time on behalf of the owner. (correct answer)
  • Only if the owner personally holds the knife.
  • Only if the slaughter happens before Eid prayer.
  • Never, because verbal permission is always required.

Why

If an animal has already been singled out for udhiyah and someone else slaughters it at the proper time on behalf of its owner, the sacrifice may still be valid. Permission to act as a proxy is normally given verbally, but it may also be established by custom and circumstances. If the situation shows that the owner permitted another person, such as a father or relative who usually handles such matters, to act on their behalf, that customary permission may take the place of explicit verbal permission.

View source on IslamQA →

2. What is the ruling on attending or watching one’s udhiyah being slaughtered?

  • It is encouraged but not required. (correct answer)
  • It is obligatory for the udhiyah to be valid.
  • It is disliked in every case.
  • It is forbidden to watch the slaughter.

Why

It is best for a person to slaughter his own udhiyah if he is able. If he cannot or does not want to do that, he may appoint someone else to slaughter it, and it is encouraged for him to attend and witness the slaughter. If he cannot bear to watch or does not want to be present, there is nothing wrong with being absent. The reward is connected to the intention, not to physical presence at the slaughter.

View source on IslamQA →

3. What is the ruling on offering a castrated animal as udhiyah?

  • It is permissible. (correct answer)
  • It is forbidden in all cases.
  • It is only valid when no intact animals are available.
  • It is invalid because castration always counts as a defect.

Why

Offering a castrated animal as udhiyah is permissible. The Prophet ﷺ sacrificed two castrated rams, which shows permissibility. He also sometimes offered intact animals, so castrated animals were not his only practice. Scholars differed over which is preferable: some preferred castrated animals because their meat may taste better, while others preferred intact animals because they are physically complete. The better choice is the animal that is fattest, has more meat, is more complete, and looks better.

View source on IslamQA →

4. When may udhiyah be offered in another country?

  • When it is done properly through a trustworthy person, especially where Muslims are in greater need. (correct answer)
  • Never, because udhiyah must always be slaughtered in one’s own city.
  • Only if the person abandons the intention of udhiyah.
  • Only if the animal is slaughtered outside the days of sacrifice.

Why

It is better for a person to slaughter the udhiyah himself in his own country, be present, mention Allah’s name, eat some, give some as gifts, and give some in charity. However, appointing someone else to slaughter is permissible. A number of contemporary scholars allowed sending udhiyah to another country when Muslims there are poorer or in greater need, provided the appointed person is trustworthy, the animal meets the conditions, and the slaughter occurs during the days of sacrifice.

View source on IslamQA →

5. If a pilgrim’s family offers an udhiyah on his behalf while he is performing Hajj, does he need to offer another udhiyah in Makkah?

  • No, the pilgrim does not offer udhiyah while on Hajj. (correct answer)
  • Yes, every pilgrim must offer both udhiyah and hadiy.
  • Yes, he must fast ten days instead of udhiyah.
  • Only if his family did not include him in their intention.

Why

The pilgrim does not offer udhiyah in Makkah; what is prescribed for him is hadiy. If he is doing Hajj Tamattu‘ or Qiraan, he must offer hadiy if able, or fast ten days if unable. If he is doing Hajj Ifraad, hadiy is not required but may be offered voluntarily. If his family remains in his homeland, it is prescribed for him to leave them money so they can offer udhiyah there.

View source on IslamQA →

6. Why is slaughtering the prescribed sacrifice better than merely giving its price in charity?

  • Because it was the practice of the Prophet ﷺ and keeps the ritual alive. (correct answer)
  • Because charity to the poor has no reward.
  • Because sacrifice is a newer form of worship.
  • Because the poor never benefit from meat.

Why

Slaughtering the prescribed sacrifice is better than giving its price in charity because this is what the Prophet ﷺ and the Muslims did, and because sacrifice is one of the rituals and symbols of Islam. If people replaced the sacrifice with charity, the visible ritual would die out. Charity may still be important in other situations, but it does not normally take the place of the prescribed sacrifice.

View source on IslamQA →

A note on these answers

These questions are for learning and self-testing. Explanations are drawn from the sources linked on each question and are not a fatwa. For a ruling on your own circumstances, please consult a qualified scholar.

More in Sacrifice & the Newborn

Browse all 281 quizzes or explore guidance topics.