The Practising Muslim · Fiqh of Salah

Imam Errors and Worshipper Corrections in Salah

Understanding how to handle mistakes by an imam and correct personal errors during prayer.

6 questions · Medium · about 4 minutes

Test yourself properly, with scoring and instant feedback.

6 questions, about 4 minutes.

Take the quiz
Show questions and answers Spoilers: every answer and explanation for all 6 questions.

1. When is al-Fatihah waived for someone praying behind an imam?

  • When they catch the imam in ruku‘, or cannot finish al-Fatihah before the imam bows. (correct answer)
  • Whenever the imam has already finished al-Fatihah.
  • Whenever the prayer is recited aloud.
  • Whenever they miss the opening du’a.

Why

Al-Fatihah is generally required for the imam, the person praying alone, and the follower. It is waived for the follower in two cases: if they catch the imam already bowing, or if they join just before the imam bows and cannot complete al-Fatihah in time. In that case, they follow the imam into ruku‘.

View source on IslamQA →

2. If the imam makes a recitation mistake outside al-Fatihah that does not change the meaning, what should followers do during the prayer?

  • They do not have to correct him during the prayer. (correct answer)
  • They must leave the prayer immediately.
  • They must repeat the prayer afterward.
  • They must correct every pronunciation mistake out loud.

Why

If the imam’s mistake is outside al-Fatihah and does not alter the meaning, followers do not have to correct him during the prayer. It is better to point it out gently after the prayer so the imam can remember and improve.

View source on IslamQA →

3. What should a follower do if they know the imam has stood for an extra fifth rak‘ah?

  • Alert the imam; if he does not respond, sit, complete tashahhud, and say salam. (correct answer)
  • Follow the imam into the extra rak‘ah knowingly.
  • Leave the prayer without salam.
  • Repeat the whole prayer immediately.

Why

If the imam is sure he is right, his own prayer remains valid, and if he later learns what happened after salam, he should do sujud al-sahw. But a follower who knows it is an extra rak‘ah should not follow him into it. The follower should alert him; if he does not respond, the follower sits, recites the final tashahhud, and says salam.

View source on IslamQA →

4. According to the Shafi‘i view cited, what should someone do if they make a mistake in al-Fatihah that changes the meaning?

  • Do sujud al-sahw after the salam. (correct answer)
  • Do nothing in every scholarly view.
  • Stop praying immediately.
  • Repeat wudu before continuing.

Why

The source mentions a difference of opinion. According to the Shafi‘i view cited, a meaning-changing mistake in al-Fatihah calls for sujud al-sahw, and it should be done after the salam because it results from adding something to the prayer. The source also notes that the Hanbalis did not require sujud al-sahw in this case.

View source on IslamQA →

5. What should someone do if they forget sujud al-sahw and remember after saying salam?

  • Do it if they remember shortly afterward; if a long time has passed, they no longer have to. (correct answer)
  • Repeat the entire prayer in every case.
  • Return to the mosque no matter how much time has passed.
  • Ignore it even if they remember immediately.

Why

If sujud al-sahw was supposed to be before the salam but the person forgot and said salam, they should do it if they remember soon afterward. If a long time has passed, their wudu was broken, or they left the mosque, they no longer have to do it, and the prayer remains valid according to the likely view cited.

View source on IslamQA →

6. If one prayer has two reasons for sujud al-sahw, one before salam and one after salam, what should the worshipper generally do?

  • Do one sujud al-sahw before the salam. (correct answer)
  • Do two separate sujud al-sahw sequences.
  • Skip sujud al-sahw because the reasons conflict.
  • Repeat the prayer from the beginning.

Why

If there are multiple mistakes in one prayer, one sujud al-sahw is enough for all of them. When one reason points to before salam and another points to after salam, the likely view cited gives precedence to doing it before salam.

View source on IslamQA →

A note on these answers

These questions are for learning and self-testing. Explanations are drawn from the sources linked on each question and are not a fatwa. For a ruling on your own circumstances, please consult a qualified scholar.

More in Fiqh of Salah

Browse all 281 quizzes or explore guidance topics.